HDR10 vs. Dolby Vision

64.5 in.

How are they different? And more importantly—can you see it?

Credit: Reviewed.com / Lee Neikirk
Our editors review and recommend products to help you buy the stuff you need. If you make a purchase by clicking one of our links, we may earn a small share of the revenue. Our picks and opinions are independent from any business incentives.

The biggest thing in TVs right now is "HDR," or High Dynamic Range. Movies that are HDR-compatible have been mastered to push TVs to their limit, with brighter highlights, deeper blacks, and a wider array of colors. Combine that with the sharper picture you get from 4K and these new movies look absolutely stunning.

Uhd guide hero

Related

The Ultimate Guide to Ultra High Definition TV

Of course, while HDR is the future, getting there is going to be messy. Currently, HDR is available in two formats: HDR10 and Dolby Vision. HDR10 is open source and backed by players like Samsung, Sony, LG, Panasonic, and Hisense.

Dolby Vision is more ambitious, but it is proprietary, and the only compatible TVs right now are LG's OLEDs, a few TVs from TCL and Philips, and the ultra rare and expensive Vizio Reference Series.

Confusing, right? We're here to help.

What sets HDR10 and Dolby Vision apart?

There are a number of key similarities and differences between the HDR10 and Dolby Vision formats. Right now, they have very similar requirements:

• Both formats require TVs to have a minimum 4K (3,840 x 2,160) resolution
• Both formats call for "wide color gamut" displays capable of ~90% of the DCI-P3 color gamut
• Both formats require TV panels and components capable of at least 10-bit color depth

bits
Credit: TJ Donegan
The 10-bit and 12-bit chroma depth wielded by HDR10/Dolby Vision displays affords them a higher degree of detail and granularity compared to "standard" 8-bit sets. View Larger

That's a big leap over current HD TVs, but that's about as far as the HDR10 standard goes. Dolby Vision is theoretically designed to go much, much further—way beyond the capabilities of today's TVs, even. That creates some major differences between the two:

• Dolby Vision mastering supports up to 10,000 nits peak brightness, with a current 4,000 nit peak brightness target
• HDR10 mastering supports up to 4,000 nits peak brightness, with a current 1,000 nit peak brightness target
• Dolby Vision mastering supports up to 12-bit color depth, HDR10 is mastered for 10 bits
• Dolby Vision mastering supports up to the BT.2020 color space, HDR10 is mastered for DCI-P3

Essentially, Dolby Vision is aiming to be a premium version of HDR10. Dolby Vision mastering uses a "color volume" process that, in short, is waiting for TVs to catch up with it, while HDR10 is being fitted to what TVs are actually capable of right now.

color-gamuts
Credit: TJ Donegan
While no current HDR TVs can produce 100% of the DCI-P3 space, and Dolby's target of Rec.2020 is still a ways off, they still boast much higher color saturation than the sets of yesteryear. View Larger

So in theory, Dolby Vision is the superior format, promising better image quality across the board. Except, there's no guarantee that display technology will ever get there. Compare HDR10 and Dolby Vision using the best TVs today and it's difficult to tell the difference.

But don't just take my word for it. We dove into a direct scene-to-scene comparison between the HDR10 and Dolby Vision versions of Mad Max: Fury Road to put Dolby's claims to the test.

Can you see the difference?

Given one of Dolby's theoretical displays—capable of 10,000 nits brightness and full BT.2020 color saturation—you would see a massive difference between current HDR10 standards and fully realized Dolby Vision. However, in the real world, the visible differences are going to come down to the TVs you're comparing.

To minimize those difference, we set up the LG OLED55B6P, one of LG's newest 2016 4K OLED TVs that supports both HDR10 and Dolby Vision. This made it fairly easy to watch content that's been mastered in both HDR10 and Dolby Vision. In this case, it was Mad Max: Fury Road on 4K Blu-ray (for HDR10) and streaming in Dolby Vision from VUDU. Both modes were left in their defaults—Dolby Vision Bright and HDR Bright, respectively—with no other settings altered other than motion smoothing, which I promptly disabled.

Compare1-SIDEBYSIDE
Credit: Reviewed.com / Lee Neikirk
While HDR10 and Dolby Vision look almost identical (on the same TV) at first glance, a careful study slightly favored Dolby Vision, which was less red-tinted and handled gradations slightly better. View Larger

To the untrained eye, or at a casual glance, the HDR10 and Dolby Vision editions of Mad Max: Fury Road looks almost identical. But as it stands right now, I'm heartily convinced that the Dolby Vision version looks just a little better.

Fellow TV reviewer Michael Desjardin and I both agreed that—probably because the Dolby Vision version was down-sampling from a superior master using 12-bit and a theoretical Rec.2020 color space—it had better gradated coloration and a slightly sharper, more balanced look than the HDR10 disc. This is really saying something, too, considering the Dolby Vision version was streaming from Vudu, and the HDR10 version was playing from a Blu-ray disc.

I'm convinced that Dolby Vision looks just a little better than HDR10—at least for Mad Max. Tweet It

It is worth noting that in all comparisons, the HDR10 and Dolby Vision versions of the disc allocated luminance and contrast about the same way. To our eyes, the major differences came down to white balance and RGB emphasis, which are subtler elements of picture quality but still of high import.

Compare2-DV
Credit: Reviewed.com / Lee Neikirk
Take note of Max's skin tone and the detail/coloration of the war rig behind him. View Larger
Compare2-HDR10
Credit: Reviewed.com / Lee Neikirk
The HDR10 version is just slightly redder, which can muddy subtler details. Note that in terms of luminance allocation they are basically identical. View Larger

Both version of Mad Max look great, of course, and oodles better than the standard Blu-ray version, especially where peak brightness and color fidelity are concerned.

But to our eyes, the streaming Dolby Vision version is the superior master of the movie, making subtler use of HDR (wide color gamut) enhancements to add realism to sand, dirt, and skin tones without the slightly burnt, over-emphasized look of the HDR10 version reflects (by comparison).

Compare3-DV
Credit: Reviewed.com / Lee Neikirk
Again, note Furiosa's skin tone, the granularity and gradation of the sand, and the white balance of the sky in the background. View Larger
Compare3-HDR10
Credit: Reviewed.com / Lee Neikirk
It's worth pointing out that differences in detail preservation and skin tone may be noticeable in these side-by-side comparisons, but they don't stand out when watching either format alone. View Larger

Does that mean Dolby Vision is superior to HDR10? Not exactly. While Dolby's colorists and mastering engineers do, in fact, have a larger artist's palette to work with (given their higher mastering targets compared to HDR10), it's definitely a movie-to-movie basis.

There are still fewer Dolby Vision-capable TVs and Dolby Vision-ready content compared to HDR10, and overall it's a more expensive ecosystem because it's proprietary to Dolby.

That's not to say you're paying more for subtler reds and better skin tones—but that's kind of what you're paying for right now, given the limitations of the hardware. Ultimately, however, we're hoping to see the HDR TVs of 2017 adopting both standards universally so as to mend the need to choose between one or the other.

Stay tuned for another look at the pros and cons of HDR10 and Dolby Vision—we plan to do a side-by-side shootout between the "HDR standard" Samsung KS9800 and the Vizio Reference Series, the first Dolby Vision TV on the market.

Our editors review and recommend products to help you buy the stuff you need. If you make a purchase by clicking one of our links, we may earn a small share of the revenue. Our picks and opinions are independent from any business incentives.

What's Your Take?

All Comments
Our editors review and recommend products to help you buy the stuff you need. If you make a purchase by clicking one of our links, we may earn a small share of the revenue. Our picks and opinions are independent from any business incentives.
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below